Fall Regatta Fifth Race Day, Nov. 14, 2015
A Z-Cat Day
For the last
Regatta of the Fall Regatta Series, 3 boats came to the starting line. Matsya
with George Boger crewing, Z-Cat and the usual crew, and No Lizard with Tyler
Nales (a student at Henderson) crewing.
The winds
were light out of the SE. The start/finish line was set up at B near the
Island, running SW to NE. Marks were set up at K and I in anticipation that the
wind would shift toward the south.
The first
race was B to K to B, port rounding. No Lizard and Z-Cat got off a good start.
Matsya was a bit behind, and it got worse for her as the wind started dying at
that end of the lake. Z-Cat got to the mark first with No Lizard close. No
Lizard got the spinnaker up, and made it back first, then Z-Cat, and Matsya
having a hard time making up for no wind on her first leg.
![]() |
Matsya "looking" for wind |
The course for the second
race was moved to I as the wind indeed started shifting toward the south. The
course was B to I to B, Port rounding. All boats got off to a good start. Z-Cat
again made the mark first. All fought the wind, sometimes blowing at 4 to 6
(maybe!) or, barely 1 with the lake glassing over. Again, with the help of the
spinnaker, No Lizard got home first, then Z-Cat 1 minute behind, followed by
Matsya.
![]() |
Eddie relives a scene from "Titanic" |
Between
races, the Assistant Committee moved I more NE in order to line up better to
the wind, AND to shorten the course due to the unpredictable wind.
The third
race was again B to I to B, port rounding. No Lizard started on the NE pin on
port. Z-Cat started from down the line from the SW on starboard. Just after the
start, No Lizard had to tack out of Z-Cats starboard line. Matsya started in
better position. Z-Cat made it to the pin first, with No Lizard right there.
![]() |
Teamwork |
This was the
theme of the day; Z-Cat, with her Baby Butt Bottom and light weight, making
good time upwind, No lizard making up time downwind with her spinnaker.
Matsya was
having a better race staying much closer to the others.
Now, it gets
interesting. Coming to the finish line, Z-Cat
decided to have some fun, and force No
Lizard away from the finish line and possibly into third place behind Matsya.
No Lizard was on a port run coming to
the SW end of the finish line. Z-Cat,
closer to No Lizard at the finish
than previously, also on a port run and leeward of No Lizard, claimed her leeward rights and started forcing No Lizard into the SW pin (allowed under
the pre-2013 rules. More later). The boats were drifting in close quarters to
each other and the buoy. With the buoy just feet away, and Z-Cat just inches away, No
lizard’s captain, being just a bit irritated, ordered the crew to grab Z-Cat’s shroud (yes, she was that close)
and pull Z-Cat into the buoy causing
her to foul the buoy!!! (yes, the buoy was that close). Fortunately for No Lizard her crew mutinied and did not follow
through. Because of Z-Cat’s mischief No Lizard had
no choice but to bear off to the west, drop her spinnaker, and circle around to
get back to the finish line. In the slight
winds and close quarters, Z-Cat
tapped No Lizard. No
Lizard protested the contact and Z-Cat took a 360 penalty turn.
I want to close by thanking all of the people who have helped me this year. Without Ron Nash agreeing to fill in for me during my absences I could not have agreed be the "Race Guy". Over the year many of you saved me literally hours by picking up the marks after the races. And I especially appreciate the lack of complaints when I goofed up running the races. I'm looking forward to racing in 2016.
Keith Sugg
Now, it is
possible that Matsya will correct on No Lizard for second place. No Lizard will be P’O’ed if his “friends”
on Z-Cat were successful!!! We shall see
when the Race Committee calculates the results.
Thanks to Ron
for providing that colorful narrative and the race photos. I have felt his pain many times.
Before I get
to the results though, this is an excellent example to help understand the
rules. IMYC is definitely not a
Blood-and –Guts racing club. But thinking
through various scenarios is a great way for us all to get more comfortable
with the rules and less intimidated by them.
So how did Ron come to his conclusion... and is he right?
First let’s
look at some of the definitions:
Mark - An object the sailing instructions
require a boat to leave on a specified side, and a race committee boat
surrounded by navigable water from which the starting or finishing line
extends. An anchor line or an object attached accidentally to a mark is not
part of it.
Zone - The area around a mark within a
distance of three hull lengths of the boat nearer to it. A boat is in the zone
when any part of her hull is in the zone.
Regarding
being forced beyond the end of the finish line:
There are four basic right-of way rules, and several
limitations. I usually approach a rules
question on the water or after the fact by first applying these four in their
order of priority (Not tacking, Starboard, Leeward, Ahead (NtSLA)), then
looking for limitations.
(1)
Nt – Not Tacking does not apply because
neither is tacking.
(2)
S – Starboard does not apply because both are
on the same tack.
(3)
L – Leeward DOES apply because one is
leeward. The fourth basic rule (ahead vs
astern) is not material since the higher priority “Leeward” rule applies, and if they are overlapped then one cannot be ahead.
What does the basic
“Leeward” rule say?
a.
Rule 11 ON THE SAME TACK, OVERLAPPED
When boats are on the same tack and overlapped, a windward
boat shall keep clear of a leeward boat.
Based on this rule it appears Z-Cat
can luff No Lizard up and away
from the finish.
But are there any other limitations? Two come to mind.
One common limitation that applies when one boat is passing
another is found in Rule 17 ON THE SAME TACK; PROPER COURSE
If a boat clear astern becomes overlapped within two of her hull lengths
to leeward of a boat on the same tack, she shall not sail above her proper
course while they remain on the same tack and overlapped within that
distance, unless in doing so she promptly sails astern of the other boat. This
rule does not apply if the overlap begins while the windward boat is required
by rule 13 to keep clear.
In essence this rule says
that if you are a leeward boat that is passing then you cannot sail above your
proper course while overlapped. But if
you are being passed it does not prohibit you from exercising your
leeward rights.
Maybe that could apply here, but there is another limitation
that definitely does. It is found in Rule 18 Mark Room (pertinent parts
below)
18.2 Giving Mark-Room
(b) If
boats are overlapped when the first of them reaches the zone, the outside boat
at that moment shall thereafter give the inside boat mark-room. If a boat is
clear ahead when she reaches the zone, the boat clear astern at that moment
shall thereafter give her mark-room.
Either end of the finish line certainly qualifies as a mark
since the sailing instructions require a boat to leave it on a specified side.
So it is clear that IF No Lizard
and Z-Cat were overlapped when the
first one reached the Zone (3 of her boat lengths from the mark), THEN the
outside boat (Z-Cat) must give the
inside boat (No Lizard) room at the
mark.
From
the race narrative it appears likely that there was such an overlap at the
zone, and that technically Z-Cat fouled
No Lizard by forcing her to the wrong
side of the mark.
There is no
rule that explicitly prohibits a crew member from grabbing another boat to
alter her course. If this had actually
happened, two rules immediately come to mind.
Rule 4 AVOIDING CONTACT
A boat shall avoid contact with
another boat if reasonably possible. However, a right-of-way boat or one
entitled to room or mark-room
(a) need not act to avoid contact
until it is clear that the other boat is not keeping clear or giving room or
mark-room, and
(b) shall be exonerated if she breaks
this rule and the contact does not cause damage or injury.
So
even if No Lizard had violated Rule 4
and initiated contact, she “shall be exonerated if she breaks this rule and the
contact does not cause damage or injury”.
The more important rule is
Rule 2 FAIR SAILING
A boat and her owner shall compete in
compliance with recognized principles of sportsmanship and fair play. A boat
may be penalized under this rule only if it is clearly established that these
principles have been violated. A disqualification under this rule shall not be excluded
from the boat’s series score.
Grabbing a competitor’s shroud and pulling her into the mark
would clearly violate the principles of sportsmanship and fair play, and may
result in being scored as a DSQ for that race.
I hope this rules discussion has helped clarify a few
issues. Now on to the results…
Last Fall
Regatta, Nov. 14, 2015
Z-Cat does
it again with three bullets! Congrats
Eddie. Its starting to sound like a broken record. Good work guys. In case you are wondering, her near three
minute margin in the last race was enough that even if she had thrown in another
penalty turn she’d still have won. See
the numbers right below.
Now that we
have the last races behind us we can proceed to the 2015 Fall Series standings. Team Zeiler Wins again! Eddie and Frank pulled off another series win. But this time the scores are much closer than in the spring. Only 2.5 points separate Z-Cat from No Lizard. Just a total of 58 seconds strategically placed would have changed the series winner. If on Nov 7 in the first race No Lizard had been only 2 seconds faster and Matsya 35 seconds faster, and on Oct 3 in race 2 No Lizard had been 21 seconds faster, the positions would have changed enough that No Lizard would have won the series.
I continue to be impressed with how competitive our racing has become. I don't mean competitive in the cut throat sense. I mean competitive in that on any given day you don't know who will come out on top, and probably by a small margin.